5 Best Milkshake Makers to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth

Updated 13 Jul 2022

Why Trust RevuuBuddy?

We spend thousands of hours researching, evaluating, and testing items to recommend the best options for the customers. We only get paid if you purchase anything through one of our links, and all of our product opinions are our own.

Finding the correct product can be difficult and time-consuming. You might not have time to do it yourself, so let us help you. RevuuBuddy reviews thousands of items in hundreds of categories, including home appliances, toys, camping supplies, and everything in between.

We compare the most popular brands and models, and we boil them down to the top five to give you the most in-depth and dependable buying recommendation - so you can make the best buying decision possible.

BEST OF THE BEST

How We Tested

These products are recommended based on a thorough research process that aims to cut through the clutter and uncover the best products in this category. We spend hours looking into the elements that matter with the assistance of experts to provide you with these options.

Models Considered

180

Consumers Consulted

Hours Researched

Updated 13 Jul 2022

Written by

Revuu Buddy

Hamilton Beach DrinkMaster Classic

BOTTOMLINE
Trusted Brand
This top mixer exceeds all expectations, transporting you back to the soda-fountain days.

PROS
Features a 70-watt motor and is backed by more than a century of manufacturing expertise. A 70-watt motor powers the mixer. The machine delivers on its promise of tasty milkshakes from a fun device. The cup holds up to 28 ounces. A footed pedestal improves balance.

CONS
The shakes this machine creates are delicious but don't expect anything more.

Check Price

Nostalgia MLKS100COKE Coca-Cola Two-Speed Milkshake Maker

BOTTOMLINE
Bargain Pick
This Coca-Cola red mixer is a keepsake maker for mixers.

PROS
Garners outstanding ratings for simplicity of use. A kid-friendly design. Adults who are nostalgic for the renowned brand will enjoy working with this machine. There's a 2-speed mixer with a 65-watt motor included in the package.

CONS
It's not as sophisticated as similar goods.

Check Price

Brentwood Classic Milkshake Maker

BOTTOMLINE
Classic Design
A tiny, retro-style milkshake maker that makes tasty shakes without effort.

PROS
Features a 2-minute timer to make a tiny milkshake. The locking mixing cup secures the contents of the 15-ounce cup, preventing spills. Rubber feet provide a sturdy, non-slip base for stability.

CONS
Height-adjustable, although it may be smaller than anticipated.

Check Price

Hamilton Beach Pro Retro Die-Cast Mixer

BOTTOMLINE
Retro Original
This model from the original milkshake maker company embracesthe retro feel.

PROS
For a vintage feel, this mixer will appeal to you. It's constructed of die-cast aluminum with a solid pedestal base for stability. There is a large, 28-ounce stainless steel mixing cup. 100-watt motor with simple controls mixes beverages and comes with a tilt-back head for convenience. For comfort, the machine has a tilt-back head.

CONS
Some customers say the motor burns out. The spindle is not detachable.

Check Price

Nostalgia Two-Speed Milkshake Maker

BOTTOMLINE
Brightly Colored
This lovely milkshake maker features an attractive design and simple maintenance.

PROS
Mixes softened ice cream and fountain drinks with a two-speed, 100-watt motor. Stainless steel mixing cup is included with 16 ounces. For simpler cleaning, the top of the head may be tilted back, and the spindle can be removed. The weighted base aids in stability.

CONS
Short-term usage has been reported to cause the motor to burn out.

Check Price

Buying Guide for Best Milkshake Makers

Don't be limited by what you have available; instead, create your own thick, rich milkshake. Do you get tired of sipping runny shakes created in your high-powered blender? A milkshake machine is intended to produce thick, delicious shakes comparable to those available at a cafe. Forget about bringing everyone out for poor subs from a fast-food restaurant. Instead, with a machine that is simple to use and clean, enjoy delectable sweets in the comfort of your own home.

With some delicious, homemade milkshakes, make your next movie night a real treat for the entire family.

The most important feature to consider when buying a milkshake maker is size. Because a milkshake maker is generally smaller than a blender, it may be more easily accommodated on your countertop.

MILKSHAKE MAKERS VS. BLENDERS

Hand blenders and countertop blenders are powerful devices with blades that may crush ice, chop nuts, purée soup, and more.

Milkshake makers, on the other hand, are built for making milkshakes. They quickly thicken and blend cold ingredients without the need for blades, using a long shaft and an aeration disk that adds air to the mix. A milkshake maker, on the other hand, produces creamier, thicker results than a blender when it comes to preparing thick, milk-based beverages. Because most versions have a detachable cup, the mixing process is easier to manage.

Because milkshake makers are less powerful, you may believe they cannot compare to blenders, but milkshake makers excel at one thing: creating delectable shakes.

BENEFITS OF HAVING A MILKSHAKE MAKER

If you own a countertop blender, you might be wondering why you should invest in a milkshake maker. Here are some good reasons:

Kids: Homemade milkshakes are a wonderful treat for children.
Fun: For gatherings and family get-togethers, making your own milkshake is a lot of fun.
Cool: A milkshake at a barbecue on a hot summer day is the best thing ever.
Cost: There's no need to spend money on several drinks for the whole family.
Control: You may choose what goes into your milkshake, provided it's healthy.
Décor: It is a fantastic addition to any retro-themed kitchen or bar area.

"Because milkshake mixers don't have blenders' sharp blades, they're considerably safer to utilize."

STAFF

Revuu Buddy

SHOULD YOU BUY A MILKSHAKE MAKER? FACTORS TO CONSIDER

Consider the following factors while selecting a milkshake maker for your kitchen:

Location: The majority of milkshake makers are small and fashionable enough to sit on the counter, but if you want your counters clear, make sure there's adequate room in your cupboards. Shakers are typically bigger and heavier than milkshake makers, with a shaker function.

Construction: You should go for stainless steel milkshake makers with components. It's simple to maintain, and the cup will help keep your shakes chilly.

Power: You don't need the same amount of strength to create milkshakes as you do to crush ice or create frozen fruit smoothies. A milkshake machine, unlike a blender, is built to aerate and combine dairy-based ingredients. The majority of milkshake machine motors are in the range of 65 and 100 watts. When it comes to combining milkshakes, more power isn't necessarily better. High-speed mixing might actually have an effect on the consistency of your finished product.

Cup capacity: How many people are you serving? The majority of milkshake machines include detachable cups that can hold up to 28 ounces of delicious, smooth goodness. It's simple to clean the cup and start another batch, but if you're catering to a crowd, search for a machine with several cup attachments.

Cleaning ease: Cleaning a milkshakes machine with stainless steel components that can be removed is simple.

Speeds: A milkshake doesn't need a lot of power, but having two settings is useful. To ensure that you're mixing and frothing your milkshake to perfection, many units have two or more speeds to pick from.

Weight: It's also important to have a solid foundation since it prevents the machine from tipping over and makes controlling the mixing procedure if you remove the cap from the device simple.

The number of cups: Some milkshake makers include extra cups, making it simple to serve a large group. Some ice cream makers include retro-style serving glasses, but they may be purchased separately if you want to serve your ice cream creations in style.

MILKSHAKE MAKER PRICES

Finding a simple one-cup milkshake maker in the $30 to $40 price range should not be difficult. The motor on a blender is usually more powerful, and the stainless-steel finish is generally more beautiful. For more than $100, you'll find shake machines and blenders with extra-capacity milkshake-producing options.

TIPS

When adding ingredients, proceed with caution. The components might flow out if you fill the container to capacity.
Last, add in chocolate chips and peanut butter. These ingredients taste wonderful in a shake, but they should be added last to ensure that they combine properly and don't block the machine.
For the best results, use chilly ingredients. The frothier your milkshake, the colder your ingredients should be.
Fill the cup with the wet stuff first. Then add the rest of your ingredients.
To keep germs at bay, clean your equipment after each usage. When creating milkshakes, this is especially crucial since you'll be mostly utilizing dairy products, which deteriorate rapidly.
Choose consistency. Because using less milk creates a thicker milkshake, make any necessary adjustments.

FAQ

Q. What's the difference between a smoothie and a milkshake?

A. A smoothie is made primarily of fruit, and the majority of smoothies are vibrant beverages. Milkshakes are thicker than smoothies and frequently include whipped cream on top. These smoothies are definitely more of a dessert and indulgence than most smoothies.

Q. Is it possible to make anything other than a milkshake with a milkshake maker?

A. Yes, sure. Most machines are capable of mixing scrambled eggs and smoothies together. If you don't have the cash or space for a high-end stand mixer, consider using your milkshake machine to prepare pancake or waffle batter for breakfast. It can also be used to mix beverages for your next cocktail gathering.

Q. Is it worth investing in a milkshake maker if I already own a blender?

A. Why not, if you have the room? When it comes to producing foamy, creamy milk-based beverages, a milkshake machine is unrivaled. If you truly enjoy milkshakes, this is the most effective method to get a real-tasting one. When it comes to making milkshakes, a blender just isn't enough. Not aerating and frothing, but rather cutting and mixing.

Q. I'm lactose intolerant, and it would be nice to be able to have milkshakes that I can consume. Is there a way for me to enjoy milkshakes?

A. Yes! There are several lactose-free milk and ice cream alternatives available to use in luxurious milkshakes.

Q. My milkshake is too runny. How can I make it thicker?

A. Did you add too much milk, or was the milk not cold enough? To help thicken your shake, add some crushed ice. Heavy cream can also be used to create a thicker milkshake.